Notifications
Clear all

CKpool vs public pool for solo mining


Posts: 6
Customer
Topic starter
(@sonia37)
Active Member
Joined: 4 months ago

I know many people choose publicpool over other options simply for the fact that it's free, but I'm wondering if the pools that charge actually perform any better, or they just greedy lol. One of the reasons I'm asking is this little gem I recently saw in Bitcoin Magazine:

"The reason people choose to join the Solo CK Pool is because they can leverage Kolivas’ server infrastructure for a 2% fee, which guarantees good-enough network performance — something critical for timely block propagation. If a miner solves a block but takes a few seconds to propagate their solution, they risk having another miner propagate theirs first, which would lead to an orphaned block and zero rewards for the first miner.”

CKpool takes 2% which obviously I'd rather keep, but if I'm more likely to hit a block than CKpool is a no brainer over a free pool. I'd rather have 98% of something then 100% of nothing. Any thoughts on whether the paid pools in general perform any better, and then specifically in regards to CKpool as well?

Oh and here's the full article in case you want to read it for context: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/business/how-small-solo-miners-solve-bitcoin-blocks

5 Replies
Posts: 7
Customer
(@bitaxeboss347)
Active Member
Joined: 4 months ago

It may be worth noting that no one has ever hit a block in public pool (to my knowledge), yet 14 blocks have been processed by Solo CKPool in the past few years.

Reply
Posts: 6
Customer
(@yurijoseph14)
Active Member
Joined: 4 months ago

I don't know if there a correlation between the cost of a mining pool and the performance.. you could buy the same car from two different dealerships and say one dealership gouges you on the price, but you still got the same car from both dealers. So cost does not always determine quality, but I'd assume in general terms that a pool with fees might have a better infrastructure than one without fees simply because pools cost money to run.

Reply
Posts: 6
Customer
(@kingcaptain2)
Active Member
Joined: 4 months ago

Pool performance has more to do with latency than cost. Granted, some pools may be dishonest and not payout when you hit blocks, but aside from that the biggest factor in pool quality is going to be latency. Here's a tool I found that shows the best pool based on your location: https://myminingrig.com/stratum-ping-pong/

Reply
Posts: 14
Customer
(@orrick-lindsay)
Active Member
Joined: 4 months ago

Piggy backing on the above comment about latency, make sure if your pool has regional end points that you pick the closest one.. I assume the tool above would already do that for you, but if not, be sure to select the url that is nearest your location. For example solo pool has separate urls for europe and america, and braiins even has a separate mining pool just for the eastern united states.

Reply
Posts: 15
Customer
(@hallie52)
Eminent Member
Joined: 4 months ago

public pool crashes more often tho.

Reply
Share: